7 Best City Island Restaurants in New York

A visit to New York City is incomplete without a trip to City Island, especially in summer, the nearest to a New England coastal town without having to leave the city. Ever visited this place? Take a cab or a friend’s car and drive into the old village area connected with a bridge street on the island of the Bronx. No issue parking at this place as almost every restaurant offers parking for free, and plenty of street parking is readily accessible.

If you want to enjoy your visit and make a day out, get off the island and explore their various seafood cuisine at seaside restaurants. Of course, you’re on City Island to eat. Here are the best restaurants to go to in New York City:

List of Top 7 City Island Restaurants in New York

Artie’s Steak & Seafood Restaurant

Best Island restaurant in 2022 (New York City)

This well-known, laid-back local restaurant serves old-fashioned surf and turf cuisine accompanied by Italian touches. Artie’s restaurant serves both indoor and outdoor dining meals and takeaway orders.

Read more
  • Address: 394 City Island Ave, The Bronx, NY 10464, United States
  • Website: www.artiescityisland.com
  • Ratings: 4.4 Star Ratings with 1,072 Google Reviews
  • Hours: Sunday – Thursday: 11:30am – 10pm & Friday – Saturday: 11:30am – 11pm
  • Phone: +1 718-885-9885

Sammy’s Shrimp Box

Best restaurant in New York City Island 2022

The quantity of Sammy’s Shrimp Box and the best sidewalk seating are two reasons you should go to Sammy’s. The restaurant also allows reservations for weekends, which is an important advantage for groups and impatient foodies.

Read more
  • Address: 41 City Island Ave, The Bronx, NY 10464, United States
  • Website: www.sammysfishbox.com
  • Ratings: 4.3 Star Ratings with 8,734 Google Reviews
  • Hours: Sunday-Thursday: 11 am-11 pm & Friday-Saturday: 11am-12pm
  • Phone: +1 718-885-0920

Also Read: 10 Best Places to Live in Canada – 2023

City Island Lobster House

City Island Lobster House - bridge street New York City

Lobster is a prominent feature on City Island Lobster House’s menu, with choices including lobster clam baked broiled or steamed lobsters that range starting at 1.25 pounds to 6 pounds, and BBQ Lobster Feast with whole lobster babies back ribs shrimp fried, lobster legs from the snow crab.

Read more
  • Address: 691 Bridge St, The Bronx, NY 10464, United States
  • Website:  cilobsterhouse.com
  • Ratings: 4.4 Star Ratings with 4,441 Google Reviews
  • Hours: Sun-Sat: 11:30 am-11 pm
  • Phone: +1 718-885-1459

Johnny’s Reef

Best restaurant in New York City Island 2022

A major part of The City Island’s experienced seafood market, Johnny’s Reef, at 2 City Island Avenue, has served fresh seafood for more than 60 years.

Read more
  • Address: 2 City Island Ave, The Bronx, NY 10464, United States
  • Websitejohnnysreefrestaurant.com
  • Ratings: 4.4 Star Ratings with 7,779 Google Reviews.
  • Hours: Monday-Thursday: 11:30am-9:30pm
  • Friday-Saturday: 11:30am-11:00pm
  • Sunday: 11:30am-10pm
  • Phone: +1 718-885-2086

Ray’s Cafe

city island restaurants in New York City

At 205 City Island Avenue, one such restaurant is Ray’s Cafe, which serves Spanish, Puerto Rican, American and Mexican cuisine.

Read more
  • Address: 205 City Island Ave, The Bronx, NY 10464, United States
  • Website: www.rayscaferestaurant.com
  • Ratings: 4.3 stars & 63 Google reviews
  • Hours:  Monday- Friday: 7 am–7 pm
  • Sunday: Closed
  • Saturday: 7 am–6 pm
  • Phone: (347) 346-9119

Vistamar

Best restaurant in New York City Island 2022

Specialized in Puerto Rican cuisine, Vistamar is one of the few Latin American choices available on the City Island. 

Read more
  • Address: 565 City Island Ave, The Bronx, New York 10464, United States
  • Website: www.vistamarcityisland.com
  • Ratings: 4.2 Star Ratings with 1,251 Google Reviews
  • Hours: Sun – Thu: 12 pm – 12 am
  • Fri-Sat: 12 pm – 2 am
  • Phone: +1 718-709-0888

The Original Crab Shanty

New York city island bronx restaurant

For those who love crab, the Banquet for Crab Love includes crab cakes with garlic crab, filled Dungeness crab softshell crab, and snow crab legs. Crab is also included in their Italian choices like Pasta del Mar or Pasta Alaska featuring the Alaskan King Crab leg chunks.

Read more
  • Address: 361 City Island Ave, The Bronx, NY 10464, United States
  • Website: originalcrabshanty.com
  • Ratings: 4.3 Star Ratings with 3,954 Google Reviews
  • Hours: Sunday-Saturday: 11 am-11 pm
  • Phone: +1 718-885-1810

Ohana Japanese Hibachi Seafood & Steakhouse

New York city island bronx restaurant, 691 bridge

The sole Japanese eatery on the island, Ohana is located at 500 City Island Avenue, and offers the hibachi experience, with a particular focus on seafood.

Read more
  • Address: 500 City Island Ave, The Bronx, NY 10464, United States
  • Website:  ohanany.com
  • Ratings: 4.3 Star Ratings with 1,293 Google Reviews.
  • Hours: Sunday – Thursday: 1 pm – 11 pm
  • Friday – Saturday: 1pm – 12am
  • Phone: +1 718-885-0700

Archie’s Tap & Table

city island restaurants in New York City

Archie’s Tap & Table are pleased to introduce its brand-new full bar at City Island, NY! Serving all of your favourite classic cocktails and our unique selections and made-to-order drinks this summer, whatever your cravings may be.

Read more
  • Address: 536 City Island Ave, The Bronx, NY 10464, United States
  • Website: archiestap.com
  • Ratings: 4.6 stars & 154 Google reviews
  • Phone:  7188859229
  • Hours:  
  • Friday: 3 am–10 pm
  • Saturday: 9 am–3 pm, 5 – 10 pm
  • Sunday: 9 am–5 pm
  • Monday & Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday & Thursday: 5 am–10 pm

The Black Whale

city island restaurants in New York City

The Black Whale, one of City Island’s most well-liked restaurants, offers a selection of American bistro classics and a few Mediterranean and Latin American dishes. The restaurant, located at 279 City Island Avenue, is reminiscent of an antique store thanks to its vintage street signs, barber pole, old-fashioned seats, and lighting.

Read more
  • Address: 279 City Island Ave, The Bronx, NY 10464, United States
  • Website: theblackwhalefb.wixsite.com
  • Ratings: 4.5 stars & 396 Google reviews
  • Phone: 7188853657
  • Hours:
  • Friday: 4–9:45 pm
  • Saturday: 4–9:45 pm
  • Sunday: 4–8:30 pm
  • Monday & Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday & Thursday: 4–9:45 pm

Leave a Reply